As the right wing of American politics loses power and credibility, it also becomes more fearful, more radical, and more dangerous. Out of fear and radicalism it will, increasingly, turn to terror (it has already happened). It is a very dangerous time in American politics. Animals are always more dangerous when wounded, and the radical right is now a wounded, lumbering beast. Be afraid, be very afraid.
The wingnuts are haunted by the essential delusions that lie at the heart of conservatism. These delusions--these lies that conservatives tell themselves--are inherently contradictory and dissonant. They are cancers eating away at the dark heart of right wing America, and unless excised they will destroy conservatism--but not perhaps before conservatism destroys us. The problem is that rather than excise these cancers, the rabid right will instead lash out at the rest of us in anger and recrimination. Recent acts of rightwing terrorism are just signs of what is to come. But first, let's look at the two essential, ineluctable contradictions that conservatism can never surmount.
First is their belief that life was better in an earlier America. Conservatism is fundamentally an appeal to the past. Conservatives believe that prior to the 60's all was good in the towns and suburbs of America: crime was low, the USA was respected around the world, the middle class was prosperous and thriving, and everyone was hanging out in their backyards cooking burgers and talking about how great it was to be in America.
This version of America, so hallowed by conservatism, is a bright and shining lie. It never existed. Prior to the 60's America was a nation of racism, crime, and class resentment; all the 60's did was to show everyone exactly where the fault lies were.
America emerged from the Great Depression by only by dint of World War II (a resounding victory against Nazism, yes, but also one in which the Soviets did most of the heavy lifting), which was immediately followed by the Cold War and witch hunts for communists. Schools and neighborhoods were utterly segregated by race and by class. Gays were arrested for their lifestyle, and anyone who did not look and live like Beaver Cleaver knew exactly where he stood in the grand scheme of America the Beautiful: on the bottom. If you were rich and white, then life was peachy keen, but that's always been the case. For everyone else, life sucked, and there was less of it (lower life expectancy).
For decades conservatism was able to persuade legions of white Americans to vote for Republican candidates by motivating them through their resentment over the loss of an America that in fact never existed. Modern conservatism is deluded at its core. It is partly for this reason that the Republican party is dying; the rest can be ascribed to demographics.
The resentful whites who gave victory to the Reaganauts, year after year, are old and dying daily by the bushel basketful (maybe it wasn't so bad that so many of them smoked after all). Young people today grow up in an America with only distant memories of the Cold War, or of desegregation, or of hippies and the threat they posed to Nixon's Silent Majority. Today's young are multicultural and multiracial. They all know someone who has gay parents. They are much less frightened by people who are different. It's no wonder that the Republican party is shrinking.
The other great flaw inherent in modern conservatism is the essential contradiction between liberty and authority. Conservatives maintain that they are for liberty, while at the same time appealing to a sense of moral authority that would severely circumscribe the behavior and lifestyle of many of our fellow citizens. One cannot advocate liberty while simultaneously appealing to authority. Liberty and authority are mutually exclusive.
The libertarian strain of right wing politics sees government regulation as antithetical to freedom, and freedom to be the only worthy state of being. These are the gun nuts and "black helicopter" conspiracy-theory folks. They ally themselves, uneasily, with the big business, low tax types who believe first and foremost in laissez-faire capitalism. Libertarians believe that the less government the better, and that people should be free to buy or do and shoot whatever they want to buy or do or shoot without any interference from the government. Their hero is Barry Goldwater.
But this libertarian strain of modern conservatism is in direct opposition to the authoritarian strain of conservatism. The authoritarian strain of conservatism seeks to intrude actively into the lives of ordinary citizens. For example, it wants to strictly regulate reproductive rights by outlawing abortion and birth control It seeks to actively promote religious education by mandating prayer in the public schools. It would legislate matters of lifestyle by denying rights to gay people. Rather than laissez-faire economics, it would strictly regulate what could and could not be sold in the market place (no pornography, for instance). Authoritarians support governmental activism for the purpose of enforcing what they see as social norms. They have no problem with Big Brother so long as they get to be Big Brother. Their hero is George W. Bush.
But how can libertarians and authoritarians ever reconcile their views? They cannot. The party of Barry Goldwater and the party of George Bush cannot coexist in the same big tent (Goldwater, by the way, hated the faux populism, self-righteousness, and sheer stupid vapidity of the religious right). Those who promote liberty are fundamentally opposed to those who champion authority instead.
While the politics of resentment allowed those two opposing camps to unite against progressives, the conflict inherent in these two philosophies simmered just beneath the surface. With the waning of the resentment that animated the right during the last 30 years, the conflict between liberty and authority is now exposed for all to see. The next presidential primary season is going to fun to watch.
And so we have the two delusions that haunt the heart of conservatism: the worship of a past that never actually existed, and the conflict between liberty and authority. Rather than acknowledge and confront these inconsistencies, the right wing instead has hunkered down into total denial mode. It now sees itself as beset by enemies on all sides: a bastion of white patriotic folk surrounded by a polyglot horde of effete, multi-hued internationalists hell-bent on instructing children in multiculturalism and pansexuality.
This is why we will see increasingly desperate acts of rightwing domestic terrorism. The rabid right can never admit that it is a political philosophy that is based on lies and delusions, and it can never change without first facing up to its essential contradictions. And these demented souls can never rest until everyone is as frightened as they are. They despise progressives for our moral consistency and basic good will. They envy us our mental health. Thus we will see more acts of revenge and terror carried out by lone-wolf cells of determined radical right-wing vigilantes. They will not let us know peace but instead are driven to extract their imbecilic vengeance.
Be careful my friends. We are surrounded by madmen.