The right loves to demagogue the immigration issue because it stirs up its racist xenophobic base. Conservative politicians are full throated in their calls for a "secure" border (i.e., a Berlin wall across the bottom of Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and California). But the plutocrats who finance the right need a porous border. They want nothing so much as plenty of continued illegal immigration because it gives them cheap labor for their meat factories and construction sites and restaurants and mansions. The right wing elite can never admit this to is base, but it doesn't really matter because the base is too full of fear to really care--it just wants to be able to vent its anti-immigrant hate in as public a manner as possible.
The left does not want any substantive action on illegal immigration because it cares about human rights. If the border were truly closed or laws passed and enforced limiting the ability of illegal immigrants to maintain themselves in this country then millions of poor people throughout the Americas would lose their one chance of making their lives better by moving north.
Both sides know that if you really wanted to stop illegal immigration you could do it with one single action: criminalize not just illegal aliens but, more importantly, those who hire them. Make it absolutely illegal to hire someone who is not in the country legally, and enforce it with substantial criminal and civil penalties (rather than the tiny fines and lax enforcement that exist currently). Then all the work currently being done by illegals would soon dry up and with it the impetus to cross into the country without permission.
But of course this will never happen because big business needs cheap labor in order to continue the obscene profits that the plutocrats rely on to fund their lavish lifestyles. The politicos who run the Republican Party and enable the tea baggers need the racist resentment the issue stirs up in order to keep the old mean white people showing up at the polls. If there's going to be any real movement on the issue it's going to have to come from the left.
As progressives I don't think that it requires that we give up our committment to human rights to also acknowledge that we have to do something substantive about illegal immigration (and something that involves more than amnesty but which is also about the rule of law). Working American pay a price for illegal immigration, a price that is increasingly difficult for us to bear and for which progressives must acknowledge some responsibility.
A vast pool of easily accessible illegal (which means, among other things, without legal protection) labor works to suppress wages and benefits for all of us. Of course this is most acute for unskilled workers, but the overall effect of illegal wages puts a downward pressure on wages for the entire economy, including wages for the skilled. Enabling the plutocrats to exploit the status of illegal immigrants for the purpose of lining their own pockets--to siphon off wages that would go to working Americans so that the corporate fat cats can vacation in the south of France every year--insults and degrades the ability of working people everywhere to make a better life for ourselves. Illegals are exploited, and working Americans are oppressed: it's a lose-lose situation for everyone but Wall Street.
The USA has long acted as a safety valve for Central and South America--in particular for Mexico. I'm not so sure anymore that we should or could continue to do this. Mexico is approaching failed state status. It is increasingly a nation divided between oligarchs and everyone else. A significant portion of the nation's economy (a fourth or more according to some estimates) consists of remittances sent back to Mexico from family members living in our country illegally--money that props up Mexico but will never be spent in the USA (where our own economy needs it). The government of Mexico is corrupt and incompetent to the core. The military and police have been bought by the drug cartels. Mexico is collapsing in on itself and my personal prediction is that there will be a revolution there within the next ten years.
By allowing the poor and dispossessed of Mexico to pour across our border and work here illegally we allow the corrupt oligarchs of Mexico to escape the consequences of their own behavior. We delay the inevitable--social revolution--and we do so at enormous cost to our own working people: we suppress our own wages; we stoke the fires of racism and xenophobia; and we see our civil liberties eroded as they have recently been in Arizona.
The wingnuts of the right will never initiate true immigration reform--they prefer rage and racism to solutions. It is up to the left to push for reform that includes sensitivity to human rights but which also acknowledges that we can no longer allow those who hire illegal immigrants to go unpunished. We must push for economic development in Latin America that actually helps workers rather than just enriches oligarchs--and we must prepare for the coming revolution in Mexico. We must push back against the plutocrats and demagogues who pleasure themselves with hatred for "the other" while caring not one whit for the working people in their own community.
And we must do all of these things immediately, because the longer we wait the greater the costs and the consequences of the devil's deal between the left and the right.
No comments:
Post a Comment